The Redesign of Evolutionary Judaism

The tiny synagogue on West Ninety-eighth Street grows from a study group into a laboratory for an evolved faith.

increasingBearing stren­gth in each eventdecreasing

A Synagogue as Small Study Group

A Synagogue as Small Study Group Context Rabbi Joshua Gruen and his wife Sarah Blumenthal lead a small congregation in a converted brownstone parlor. There is an Ark at one end, bridge chairs for a few rows, and a growing library. The services are being redesigned around the Shema, Kaddish, the idea of the Sabbath, and the study of Torah. Significance The EJ is a green shoot in a tradition of great age, a deliberate attempt to separate the ethical essence of Judaism from the accumulated weight of custom. It treats God as ahistorical and religion as human work. The congregation becomes Pembroke? No, rather a place where Pem's questions are welcome. Consequences The small synagogue attracts people who find orthodoxy impossible and reform insufficient. Its existence sets the stage for the cross's arrival on its roof.

The Roof-Top Discovery

The Roof-Top Discovery Context Joshua climbs to his roof expecting a fire and finds the eight-foot brass cross of St. Timothy's lying there. He and Sarah decide not to call the police, fearing publicity that would destroy their new congregation. Pem arrives and recognizes the cross; the two families of faith become linked. Significance The discovery turns the synagogue roof into a symbolic battlefield. For the rabbis the cross is an execrable emblem, a template of Christian triumphalism; for Pem it is a stolen object and, later, a sign. The incident forces the EJ to define itself publicly before it is ready. Consequences The attempted suppression of the story fails because Pem is already in the news. The EJ becomes known, for better and worse, as the synagogue where the cross was found.

Friday Night Seminars

Friday Night Seminars Context Sarah leads the Friday night services, now a rabbinically directed seminar rather than a sermon. Congregants discuss the documentary hypothesis, the origins of the Ten Commandments, and the meaning of soul. Pem attends regularly, and Everett comes as a visitor. The group's numbers slowly grow. Significance The seminar model is the EJ's essential practice: no doctrine is exempt from questioning. Sarah's method is to draw out the ethical core while dispensing with the inessential or intellectually untenable. The congregation is itself an experiment in what a religious community can become. Consequences The EJ becomes a home for secular intellectuals, clergy refugees, and elderly Jews who cannot abide orthodoxy. It also becomes the setting for Pem and Sarah's deepening relationship.

The Question of the Yoke of Heaven

The Question of the Yoke of Heaven Context A newer congregant asks Sarah where the line is drawn between tradition and change. Another man insists that the Torah was given by the Creator and that without accepting the yoke of the Kingdom of Heaven there is no religion. Sarah answers with the example of Hillel and the Golden Rule, but the challenge hangs in the air. Significance The exchange exposes the central difficulty of Evolutionary Judaism: can a community survive without a moment of unmediated awe or an obligation beyond ethics? Sarah's answer points to the ethical heart of the commandments, but the old man's question cannot be fully dismissed. Consequences Pem, watching, holds his head in his hands. He recognizes the wall where rationalism meets faith, the same wall he hit in the Episcopal Church.

Seligman's Cosmological Intervention

Seligman's Cosmological Intervention Context A heavyset man rises during a discussion about tradition and delivers a stunning speech about the Creator, dark matter, galaxies, and quantum mechanics. He asks whether the honorifics Lord and King sufficiently praise the Creator of a fifteen-billion-year-old universe. Only afterward does Everett realize the man is Murray Seligman, the Nobel Prize-winning physicist who once copied his algebra homework. Significance The speech invokes modern cosmology as a new language for the sacred. It reframes the EJ's project as an attempt to think God in the manner of our times. Pem calls it a sign, though Everett resists the implication. Consequences The encounter thickens the novel's sense that revelation is ground-level, elusive, and often comical. Seligman's presence links Bronx Science, Nobel physics, and the prayer room of a radical synagogue.

at the founding of the Synagogue of Evolutionary Judaism, before the cross appears

the morning after an anonymous caller tells Joshua his roof is burning

after Joshua's death, in the first and second years of Sarah's widowhood

at the service where an elderly man challenges the rabbi's radicalism

at a crowded Friday service in the novel's later pages